Financial Distress and the Cross Section of Equity Returns

In this paper, we provide a new perspective for understanding cross-sectional properties of equity returns. We explicitly introduce financial leverage in a simple equity valuation model and consider the likelihood of a firm defaulting on its debt obligations as well as potential deviations from the absolute priority rule (APR) upon the resolution of financial distress. We show that financial leverage amplifies the magnitude of the book-to-market effect and hence provide an explanation for the empirical evidence that value premia are larger among firms with a higher likelihood of financial distress. By further allowing for APR violations, our model generates two novel predictions about the cross section of equity returns: (i) the value premium (computed as the difference between expected returns on mature and growth firms), is humpshaped with respect to default probability, and (ii) firms with a higher likelihood of deviation from the APR upon financial distress generate stronger momentum profits. Both predictions are confirmed in our empirical tests. These results emphasize the unique role of financial distress— and the nonlinear relationship between equity risk and firm characteristics—in understanding cross-sectional properties of equity returns. JEL Classification Codes: G12, G14, G33